Sheila Maura McGayhey, of Bronxville, passed away at home on July 16, 2025. Loving mother of Laura Eckley, beloved grandmother of Julia, adored sister of Peter Quinn (Kathy), Thomas Quinn (Debbie) and the late Kathleen O’Connell (Richard), and devoted godmother to James Murphy and Peter O’Connell (Christine). Sheila was born in Manhattan to the late Honorable Peter A. Quinn and Mrs.Viola Quinn in 1938 and was raised in the Parkchester section of the Bronx, spending summers at her family’s home on Shelter Island. After graduating from Preston High School, Sheila earned a BA in English from Marymount Manhattan and a Master of Education from Hunter College.
Upon marrying and becoming a mother, Sheila began her family in Parkchester and moved to Bronxville in 1982 where she quickly became an involved parent at the Bronxville School, a driver for Meals on Wheels, a member of many charitable organizations and a devout parishioner at Saint Joseph’s Roman Catholic Church of Bronxville. Formerly a NYC elementary school teacher, Sheila spent the final decade of her career working in the Resource Room of Scarsdale’s Edgewood School.
Sheila loved nature, music, children, her family and God. Being a grandmother to Julia was the greatest joy of her life and upon her retirement in 2005 she became Julia’s full time caregiver. Their relationship, shared love and bond was remarkable. Sheila devoted her life to caring for her large, loving, extended family and nursed her sister Kathleen through an end-of-life illness in 2018. She was kind to everyone and was a treasured neighbor in Bronxville’s Alden Place community for 43 years. She will be missed by her nieces and nephews and their children, her numerous friends and all who were lucky enough to have known her and enjoyed her company.
Mass of Christian Burial will take place at St. Joseph’s Church Bronxville on Saturday, August 2, 2025 at 9:45 am.
In lieu of flowers donations may be made in her memory to Jansen Hospice: www.jansenhospice.org
Memorial Mass: 9:45 am, Saturday, August 2 at St Joseph’s Church, Bronxville, NY.
In lieu of flowers donations may be made in her memory to Jansen Hospice: www.jansenhospice.org


Condolence(1)-
Sue Eilers says
August 2, 2025 at 1:40 pmI just heard of your mother’s passing away. It’s very hard to lose someone so close to you, paretnt or friend or child. Try to be comforted by the love of all your friends and collegues.