Sara “Sally” Elizabeth Williams, a Broadway performer, music teacher, and beloved mother and friend, died peacefully at home on November 13, 2026, surrounded by her family, after living with cancer for four years. She was 78.
Sally had a beautiful mezzo-soprano voice, a generous heart, and an extraordinary gift for friendship. She drew people to her easily and kept them close across decades and continents. Her life was full of people she loved, and she made the effort to let them know it.
Raised in Virginia, Sally studied at the Hartt School at the University of Hartford in Connecticut and pursued graduate work at Santa Cecilia in Rome. Working as a singing waitress at Romie’s brought her some of her oldest and dearest friends, before a career on the stage took her to New York and far beyond. She established herself on Broadway in productions including Camelot, starring first Richard Burton and later Richard Harris in the same role, and worked for many years with New York City Opera, including not only performing but also bringing opera into schools and introducing children to the art she loved.
One of the longest and most memorable chapters of Sally’s performing career was her portrayal of Madame Giry in Andrew Lloyd Webber’s The Phantom of the Opera. Her years with Phantom took her to Basel, Switzerland, and Hamburg, Germany, then across the United States on tour, before she returned to New York, where she performed in the Broadway production of Phantom, eight shows a week, for more than a decade.
After Phantom, Sally found another great love in teaching voice and piano. She delighted in her students, cared deeply about their lives, and came to regard many of them as her own children. Teaching became one of the great joys of her life—a chance to share her love of music while helping her students discover their own voices.
Sally leaves behind her sons, Samuel Patrick and Christopher Michael Madden; her longtime companion, Jonathan Guss; her brother, Robert, and his wife, Sue; her sister-in-law, Kathy; her nephew, Robert, and his wife, Virginia; and a wide circle of family and friends. She was predeceased by her parents, Robert and Ruth Williams, and her brother, Martin, Kathy’s husband. Kind, clever, creative, and full of warmth, she will be deeply missed by the many people who loved her.
A service to remember Sally will be held on Tuesday, December 1, 2026, at 11 a.m. at the Reformed Church of Bronxville in Bronxville, NY.


Leave a Condolence